release feature

Lambchop's Punching the Clown Turns a Radio Accident Into Album Number 17

Kurt Wagner heard an unidentified gospel song in early 2024 and followed it back more than a century, to a Scottish singing tradition nobody asks about anymore.

Most bands announce their seventeenth album by leaning on momentum. Lambchop is leaning on a coincidence. Sometime in early 2024, Kurt Wagner heard a gospel song on the radio — no title given, no artist attached, just a sound that snagged him — and it sent him chasing something called lined-out singing, a call-and-response vocal practice that started in Scotland in the late 1800s before drifting into Appalachia and settling, quietly, at the root of American gospel and country music. That detour is the spine of Punching the Clown, out August 21, 2026 on City Slang, and it's the reason this record is worth paying attention to even before the lead single "Weakened" plays a note.

Following The Bible is not a small assignment, and Wagner didn't treat it like one. Rather than chase a bigger sound, he went smaller and stranger, pointing an entire album at a vocal form most listeners have never consciously heard, let alone named. Lined-out singing is not a genre with a fan base or a hashtag — it's closer to a linguistic fossil, the kind of thing that shows up in ethnomusicology footnotes. Building a 2026 album around it is a genuinely odd swing, and the fact that Lambchop is the band taking it tracks with everything they've built a catalog on: turning unglamorous source material into something that sounds inevitable in hindsight.

## A Three-Day Session With a Six-Part Choir

The making of the record is almost as unusual as its premise. Punching the Clown was recorded in three days — August 25 through 27, 2025 — at Justin Vernon's April Base studio in Wisconsin, with Vernon playing banjo and Andrew Broder on guitar. Ryan Olson produced, Mark Nevers mixed, and the room also held Blake Morgan and a six-part choir, which tells you the call-and-response concept wasn't a lyrical gesture — it needed actual bodies trading lines in actual time. Twelve more singers were layered in afterward, in separate sessions in London and Minneapolis, stretching a three-day core session into something with real geographic reach. That's a small choir becoming a larger one after the fact, which is its own kind of quiet ambition: get the foundation right fast, then let the tradition's call-and-response DNA keep multiplying once the tape's already rolling elsewhere.

Three days is fast for a record built on a vocal tradition this specific — it suggests the arrangements arrived rehearsed rather than discovered in the room, with the choir work doing the heavy lifting of turning a folk history lesson into something that actually functions as a song.

## Thirty Songs Down to Twelve

Before any of that, there was the unglamorous part: years spent studying great songwriters, by Wagner's own account, specifically to sharpen his writing for this project. He wrote thirty songs. He and Olson kept twelve. That ratio — better than a coin flip, worse than a sure thing — says something about how deliberately this tracklist was cut down, and it's worth sitting with the titles that survived: "Just West Of Nicollet," "A Doctor In The House," "Weakened," "Stella," "Punching The Clown," "White People," "The New World Wave," "Andrew Jackson Asshat," "Afterburner," "Cigar," "To Do," "No Chicago." That's a lot of tonal range for twelve songs — a title like "Andrew Jackson Asshat" sitting a few tracks from "Stella" isn't an accident from a songwriter who spent years studying craft and then hand-picked survivors from a pile of thirty.

Wagner has said the goal was simple, restrained vocabulary reaching toward truth through hyper-naturalism, with grief, love, and humor as the working themes. That's a mouthful of intent for lyrics meant to sound plain, but plain-on-purpose is a harder trick than it sounds, and it's consistent with an album leaning on a singing style built for clarity over ornament in the first place. Lined-out singing exists to be followed, not admired from a distance — call, then response, no room for the response to get lost. Writing toward hyper-naturalism while structuring songs around a tradition built on legibility isn't a coincidence; it's the same instinct applied to two different tools.

For anyone who wants the physical object, Tower Records is carrying Punching the Clown on vinyl LP under UPC 673855089713, alongside listings at Stranger Than Paradise Records and Rough Trade. A niche vocal tradition getting a vinyl pressing and a multi-retailer rollout is its own small statement about where the audience for this kind of curiosity actually lives.

What's most interesting here isn't that Lambchop dug up an obscure tradition — bands raid folk history for texture all the time. It's that they built the session, the choir count, and the writing process entirely around making that tradition load-bearing rather than decorative. Whether "Weakened" telegraphs that structure or holds it back for later tracks is the first real question the album puts in front of a listener.

Releases on the radar

Artists in this guide

Explore related genre guides

Continue with related release guides

Original reporting